Just 61 complaints
Just 61 complaints to the Telephone Preference Service (TPS) helped trigger an investigation that resulted in a £105,000 fine for Bluon Energy Ltd.
Sure, they made a fair number of calls, but it wasn’t the quantity of calls that raised any issues, it was the complaints.
The power of a consumer complaint is not to be underestimated.
Complaints draw attention to your business and attention draws scrutiny. In this case the complaints drew attention to Bluon Energy Ltd which in turn put the focus on their call history and that got them the fine.
Making live marketing calls to numbers registered on the TPS or Corporate Telephone Preference Service (CTPS) requires appropriate consent. If you cannot demonstrate that consent, you have a problem.
Between 1 April 2024 and 30 April 2025 (notice how far back this goes?), Bluon made 194,379 calls to numbers registered on the TPS and CTPS.
Anyone familiar with a dialler will know that’s not an especially huge number of calls.
By all accounts, the opt-ins Bluon relied upon were found to be falling short of what’s necessary when you’re calling people registered on the TPS. You cannot rely on generalised opt-ins from data collected on marketing websites to override the TPS.
Consent can override the TPS, just not in the form of a generalised “selected third parties”, “similar organisations”, “partners” or similar vague generalisations contained in some marketing privacy policies.
Bluon purchased leads from companies that failed to meet the threshold for proper consent under the Privacy and Electronic Communications Regulations 2003 (PECR).
The account of the case also indicates that Bluon failed to provide consumers who complained with the company’s proper contact details.
The ICO has the power to issue a monetary penalty notice if it is satisfied that there has been a serious contravention of the requirements. You may not see 61 complaints as serious, especially if your business has made nearly 200,000 calls. In fact, you might be forgiven for thinking that 61 complaints was actually quite good, but you’re not the ones deciding what a ‘serious contravention’ is.
The 61 complaints led to an investigation. The investigation led to the call activity being analysed.
Bluon and/or its suppliers appear to have used multiple phone numbers during their campaigns, but this did not stop the ICO putting the pieces together.
The ICO made third-party information notice (3PIN) requests to telecoms companies to establish the bill payers behind certain numbers and obtain additional information, such as billing invoices, call logs and details of who paid what and when.
These 3PIN requests also opened up an additional list of phone numbers that were also be checked for complaints.
At this point, you have to imagine one of those crime boards you see on TV with pieces of string linking the people, companies, telephone suppliers, phone numbers and so on.
Bluon’s suppliers made the initial calls and confirmed the consumers’ desire to receive a call from Bluon. Bluon itself did not TPS screen the data that it received because it accepted it as “opt-in”. Where this fell down was Bluon’s failure to check its suppliers’ data collection processes and establish whether the initial calls were permitted.
Getting someone else to make the initial call does not remove the need to check how a lead was obtained. Businesses need evidence that any consent they rely upon meets the requirements for their own marketing calls.
This is a classic case of sticking your head in the sand and assuming “I’m sure it will be fine”.
When the ICO asked for proof of opt-in, Bluon did not provide it.
It’s also not uncommon for a lot of business in the marketing sector to be done verbally, but when things go wrong, you’ll likely be asked for copies of contracts. Bluon didn’t have those either. Again, that’s not uncommon, but do yourself a favour and get contracts with suppliers if you’re working in an industry prone to regulator scrutiny.
Bank accounts are also difficult to ‘undo’. Transactions indicating who was paid what and when never go away.
TPS Services’ Richard Kane said:
Now bear in mind in all of this that the ICO did not establish that Bluon deliberately set out to breach PECR, yet they still got fined. They did, however, establish that Bluon were negligent in calling people registered on the TPS.
In our experience, whilst it’s nice that the ICO can acknowledge no deliberate breaches occurred, the breaches occurred nonetheless so if they don’t get you for deliberately breaching PECR then they’ll get you for ‘negligently’ breaching PECR. Either way, you’ll endure the work, the stress, hassle and still get fined at the end of it and all that’s while this whole saga drags on for about a year.
Bluon now have a fine large enough that it would historically end most small businesses.